Share this article

Celsius's CEL Token May See 20 -Cent Value in Recovery Process, Attorney Says

The token currently has a market value of 54 cents.

Alex Mashinsky at Consensus 2019 (CoinDesk)
Alex Mashinsky at Consensus 2019 (CoinDesk)

An attorney for bankruptcy crypto lender Celsius Network said the company might value its CEL token at 20 cents during the recovery process, down significantly from its current market value of 54 cents.

The native token of the now-defunct crypto lender once traded at an all-time-high of $8.02 – which regulators and Celsius’ independent examiner now say was the result of price manipulation meant to benefit insiders, including former CEO Alex Mashinsky.

STORY CONTINUES BELOW
Don't miss another story.Subscribe to the State of Crypto Newsletter today. See all newsletters

In the wake of the revelations, lawyers for Celsius are wrestling with how to compensate CEL token holders without rewarding insiders who have enormous CEL holdings.

“I don’t think we’ve reached a 100% final conclusion there, but given the fact that the examiner report reveals in great detail how the price of CEL token was manipulated, we’ve really struggled with how to treat the CEL token and what is a fair value to ascribe to it,” Celsius’ lead attorney, Kirkland & Ellis's Ross Kwasteniet, told U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Martin Glenn.

“It’s our intention to suppress or subordinate the CEL token claims of insiders who were involved in the manipulation of the CEL token price,” Kwasteniet added. “It’s our intention that they would not receive any recovery or distribution on account of the CEL token.”

Celsius’ lawyers added that, if the estate were to value CEL tokens at the price of the petition date, it would take away value from the recovery given to holders of other cryptocurrencies.

Celsius customers attending the Wednesday hearing were not happy with the suggested recovery price.

“I would just hope that [the Unsecured Creditors Committee] take into consideration that a lot of the retail users did not buy [CEL] at 20 cents. We bought at all time highs, all the way down,” said pro-se creditor Jason Iovine. “It’s just more punishment on the retail users.”

UPDATE (Feb. 15, 2023, 16:30 UTC): Adds additional detail.

Cheyenne Ligon

On the news team at CoinDesk, Cheyenne focuses on crypto regulation and crime. Cheyenne is originally from Houston, Texas. She studied political science at Tulane University in Louisiana. In December 2021, she graduated from CUNY's Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism, where she focused on business and economics reporting. She has no significant crypto holdings.

Cheyenne Ligon