BTC
$106,754.57
-
0.63%
ETH
$2,637.47
-
0.14%
USDT
$1.0001
+
0.00%
XRP
$2.2782
+
0.67%
BNB
$679.46
-
0.68%
SOL
$168.42
-
1.57%
USDC
$0.9998
+
0.01%
DOGE
$0.2191
-
0.59%
ADA
$0.7358
-
1.43%
TRX
$0.2762
+
0.11%
SUI
$3.5507
-
0.66%
HYPE
$31.90
-
7.36%
LINK
$15.36
-
0.93%
AVAX
$22.77
-
1.55%
XLM
$0.2824
-
0.36%
TON
$3.3928
+
0.55%
LEO
$9.0726
+
0.11%
SHIB
$0.0₄1414
-
0.24%
BCH
$411.50
+
0.64%
HBAR
$0.1810
-
1.65%
Logo
  • News
  • Prices
  • Data
  • Indices
  • Research
  • Events
  • Sponsored
  • Sign In
  • Sign Up
Tech
Share this article
X iconX (Twitter)LinkedInFacebookEmail

Ethereum’s Buterin Expresses Concerns Over Sam Altman’s Worldcoin

Worldcoin’s identity system, “Proof-of-Personhood,” faces issues with privacy, accessibility, centralization, and security, according to Buterin.

By Margaux Nijkerk|Edited by Sam Kessler
Updated Jul 24, 2023, 3:58 p.m. Published Jul 24, 2023, 2:43 p.m.

Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin released a new blog post on Monday detailing his concerns over OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s new crypto project, Worldcoin, which launched its mainnet this week.

In the post, Buterin highlights four major concerns with Worldcoin’s user authentication system, called “Proof-of-Personhood” (PoP).

STORY CONTINUES BELOW
Don't miss another story.Subscribe to the The Protocol Newsletter today. See all newsletters
By signing up, you will receive emails about CoinDesk products and you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy.

Worldcoin claims it can authenticate its users without storing personal data or relying on a central authority. To obtain a “World ID,” users must scan their iris with a device known as an “Orb.” Compatible apps, like Worldcoin’s own wallet application, can leverage Worldcoin’s network of authenticated users to tailor their services and root out bots.

In his blog post, Buterin argues that this system has potential issues with privacy, accessibility, centralization, and security.

Read more: Worldcoin Releases Tokenomics, Report Geofenced for Some Countries

Buterin argues first that scanning one's iris could potentially release more information than intended. For instance, if someone else scans a World ID holder's iris, they can run it against the Worldcoin database to determine – at the very least – whether that person is in the system. In addition, Buterin says World IDs won’t be readily accessible to everyone, since getting ahold of an “Orb” device can be difficult.

Furthermore, the “Orb” is a hardware device, and Buterin alleges that “we have no way to verify that it was constructed correctly and does not have backdoors.” He adds that “the Worldcoin Foundation still has the ability to insert a backdoor into the system, letting it create arbitrarily many fake human identities.”

Finally, Buterin expresses security concerns with Worldcoin given that users' phones could be hacked, and they could be coerced into giving out their iris scans.

Buterin acknowledges that there is no perfect solution to overcoming these issues. “There is no ideal form of proof of personhood,” Buterin writes. “Instead, we have at least three different paradigms of approaches that all have their own unique strengths and weaknesses.” Those three approaches are known as social-graph-based, general-hardware biometric, and specialized-hardware-biometric solutions (like Worldcoin).

Buterin also adds that Worldcoin has taken certain steps with its hardware that make it superior to more traditional identification schemes – particularly when it comes to user privacy. "It does seem like specialized hardware systems can do quite a decent job of protecting privacy," says Buterin. "However, the flip side of this is that specialized hardware systems introduce much greater centralization concerns."

The newly-launched WLD token spiked earlier Monday by over 20% on major crypto exchanges, following Worldcoin’s mainnet launch.

Read more: Worldcoin's Newly-Launched WLD Token Spikes Over 20% on Major Crypto Exchanges

EthereumVitalik ButerinSam AltmanworldcoinOpen ai
Margaux Nijkerk

Margaux Nijkerk reports on the Ethereum protocol and L2s. A graduate of Johns Hopkins and Emory universities, she has a masters in International Affairs & Economics. She holds BTC and ETH above CoinDesk's disclosure threshold of $1,000.

X icon
CoinDesk News Image
Latest Crypto News
Article image

Bitcoin Whales Seem to Be Calling a Top as BTC Price Consolidates

2 hours ago

Bitcoin (BTC) price on May 19 (CoinDesk)

Bitcoin Climbs to $105K; Crypto ETF Issuer Sees 35% Upside

2 hours ago

Breaking News

Breaking New test

6 hours ago

FastNews (CoinDesk)

Fast News test

6 hours ago

Article image

Ethereum Surges 4% on Massive Volume as Institutional Interest Grows.

May 27, 2025

Article image

test research article

May 22, 2025

Top Stories
SHIB-USD 1-month chart shows 24.57% gain ending at $0.00004146 on May 15

Shiba Inu (SHIB) Price Drops 7% in 24 Hours but Remains Up 25% Over the Past Month

May 15, 2025

(CJ/Unsplash)

XRP Futures Start Trading on CME

May 19, 2025

Tax sign (The New York Public Library/Unsplash)

Crypto Capital Gains and Tax Rates 2022

Nov 14, 2022

Swap

Atomic Swaps: What Are They & How Do They Work?

Jan 11, 2024

Pancakes (Mae Mu/Unsplash)

What Is PancakeSwap? Here’s How to Start Using It

Apr 21, 2022

Futures Open Interest, CME (Glassnode)

Recent Inflows Into Spot Bitcoin ETFs Could Be Purely Directional Plays: Van Straten

Dec 4, 2024

Only 1 article remaining this month.

Sign up for free

About

  • About Us
  • Masthead
  • Careers
  • CoinDesk News
  • Crypto API Documentation

Contact

  • Contact Us
  • Accessibility
  • Advertise
  • Sitemap
  • System Status
DISCLOSURE & POLICES
CoinDesk is an award-winning media outlet that covers the cryptocurrency industry. Its journalists abide by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk has adopted a set of principles aimed at ensuring the integrity, editorial independence and freedom from bias of its publications. CoinDesk is part of the Bullish group, which owns and invests in digital asset businesses and digital assets. CoinDesk employees, including journalists, may receive Bullish group equity-based compensation. Bullish was incubated by technology investor Block.one.
EthicsPrivacyTerms of UseCookie SettingsDo Not Sell My Info

© 2025 CoinDesk, Inc.
X icon
Sign Up
  • News
    Back to menu
    News
    • Markets
    • Finance
    • Tech
    • Policy
    • Focus
  • Prices
    Back to menu
    Prices
    • Data
      Back to menu
      Data
      • Trade Data
      • Derivatives
      • Order Book Data
      • On-Chain Data
      • API
      • Research & Insights
      • Data Catalogue
      • AI & Machine Learning
    • Indices
      Back to menu
      Indices
      • Multi-Asset Indices
      • Reference Rates
      • Strategies and Services
      • API
      • Insights & Announcements
      • Documentation & Governance
    • Research
      Back to menu
      Research
      • Events
        Back to menu
        Events
        • Consensus Hong Kong
        • Consensus 2026
        • CoinDesk: Policy & Regulation
      • Sponsored
        Back to menu
        Sponsored
        • Thought Leadership
        • Press Releases
        • CoinW
        • MEXC
        • Phemex
        • Advertise
      • Videos
        Back to menu
        Videos
        • CoinDesk Daily
        • Shorts
        • Editor's Picks
      • Podcasts
        Back to menu
        Podcasts
        • CoinDesk Podcast Network
        • Markets Daily
        • Gen C
        • Unchained with Laura Shin
        • The Mining Pod
      • Newsletters
        Back to menu
        Newsletters
        • The Node
        • Crypto Daybook Americas
        • State of Crypto
        • Crypto Long & Short
        • Crypto for Advisors
      • Webinars & Events
        Back to menu
        Webinars & Events
        • Consensus 2025
        • Policy & Regulation Conference
      Select Language
      English enEspañol esFilipino filFrançais frItaliano itPortuguês pt-brРусский ruУкраїнська uk